Money & Politics

Elizabeth Warren Proposes to Strengthen Democratic Spines With a Powerful New Tool: Math

Noting that more Americans voted for Democrats, the senator says her party has a mandate to resist Trumpism.

Elizabeth Warren Proposes Math to Strengthen Democrats

Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) is urging Democrats to look at the election math, which shows that voters gave neither Donald Trump nor Senate Republicans a mandate. (Photo by Saul Loeb/AFP/Getty Images)

This post originally appeared at The Nation.

Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren is calling on Democrats to be an actual opposition party in the coming era of Trumpism. And she is deploying a powerful tool to make the case for aggressive and unapologetic resistance to Republican hegemony: math.

“Republicans are taking over Congress. They are taking over the White House. But Republicans do not have majority support in this country,” declared the progressive senator from Massachusetts on the floor of the Senate this week. “The majority of voters supported Democratic Senate candidates over Republican ones, and the majority supported a Democratic presidential candidate over a Republican one.”

Republicans are taking over Congress. They are taking over the White House. But Republicans do not have majority support in this country.

— Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA)

Warren is right when she points out that Americans did not give Trump a mandate.

In the ongoing count of the national popular vote, Democrat Hillary Clinton was leading Republican Donald Trump by 2,332,745 votes as of Tuesday afternoon. Clinton has won 48.2 percent of the vote to 46.4 percent for Trump. And Clinton’s advantage will continue to grow as states finish counting and recounting ballots in anticipation of the Dec. 13 deadline for certifying results. Trump’s claim on the presidency does not extend from the popular will — 53.6 percent of Americans who cast ballots in the Nov. 8 election opposed him — but from the Electoral College, where narrow victories in a handful of battleground states give the Republican a 306-232 lead.

That Electoral College lead may be enough to make Trump president, but it’s no landslide. In fact, as Nate Silver notes, Trump’s Electoral College advantage is “decidedly below-average.” “There have been 54 presidential elections since the ratification of the 12th Amendment in 1804,” explains Silver. “Of those 54 cases, Trump’s share of the electoral vote — assuming there are no faithless electors or results overturned by recounts — ranks 44th.”

Warren is also right when she points out that Americans did not give Senate Republicans a mandate.

Only one-third of Senate seats were up for election in 2016, and the count is complicated by state-based quirks. (The Republicans were eliminated in the California primary, setting up a November contest between two Democrats; and Louisiana’s Senate runoff won’t be held until Dec. 10.) With that said, Democrats actually picked up two US Senate seats this year and reduced the Republican majority in the chamber. And voters did indeed cast more ballots for Democratic Senate candidates than Republicans. USA Today reported shortly after the election that “The White House may not be the only institution in Washington that Democrats lost on Tuesday despite getting more votes than Republicans. It turns out that Democrats also got more votes for the US Senate than Republicans, and yet Republicans maintained their majority on Capitol Hill.” The preliminary count had Democratic Senate candidates gathering 46.2 million votes to 39.3 million for Republican candidates. Those numbers will change a good deal when the final counts are recorded — and when Louisiana settles its contest. But even if the Republican wins in Louisiana (and even if only the votes for Sen.-elect Kamala Harris, the winner of California contest, are counted), Democrats are still positioned to finish ahead in the national count. So it’s absurd to suggest that voters handed Senate Republicans a blank check to remake America. They didn’t.

If any mandate was delivered on Nov. 8, it was a charge to Congress to reject a rigged economic system in which corporate special interests call the shots. “[There] is one thing that Americans are not divided on — one issue [where] they sent a message loud and clear,” Warren told the Senate. “According to exit polls, 70 percent of voters said they think that the American economy and the lawmakers who oversee it are owned — owned! — by big companies and special interests. That’s 70 percent of everybody: Republicans, Democrats, independents.”

The voters, Warren argued, want senators to challenge the big companies and special interests and to “stand up and work for the American people.”

Warren took her own stand Monday, when she objected loudly to the so-called “21st Century Cures Act,” a piece of medical innovation legislation that Warren said had been “hijacked” by the pharmaceutical industry and its legions of lobbyists.

In mounting her objection, the senator from Massachusetts made a point about how Democrats can and must perform their duties in a closely divided Senate where the opposition retains tools for forcing debate and compromise.

Speaking of the popular vote totals that favored her party, Warren said:

The American people didn’t give Democrats majority support so we could come back to Washington and play dead. They didn’t send us here to whimper, whine or grovel. They sent us here to say “no” to efforts to sell Congress to the highest bidder. They sent us here to stand up for what’s right. Now, they are watching, waiting, and hoping — hoping we show some spine and start fighting back when Congress completely ignores the message of the American people and returns to all its same old ways.

Yes, Warren acknowledged, “Republicans will control this government.”

“But,” she concluded, “they cannot hand over that control to big corporations unless Democrats roll over and allow them to do so.”

John Nichols

John Nichols is national correspondent for The Nation. A co-founder of the media reform organization Free Press, he is the author of Horsemen of the Trumpocalypse: A Field Guide to the Most Dangerous People in America, forthcoming from Nation Books this fall, and co-author with Robert W. McChesney of The Death and Life of American Journalism: The Media Revolution that Will Begin the World Again; Tragedy & Farce: How the American Media Sell Wars, Spin Elections, and Destroy Democracy; and People Get Ready: The Fight Against a Jobless Economy and a Citizeness Democracy, published in March 2016 by Nation Books. Follow him on Twitter: @NicholsUprising.