Who Will Stand Up to Wall Street?

  • submit to reddit

This post first appeared in In These Times


Wall Street

(AP Photo/Henny Ray Abrams)

Wall Street held itself a big fat profit party last week. The nation’s six largest banks reported $23 billion in profits. That’s for one quarter — three months. Pop the champagne. Buy another Lamborghini.

Well, if you’re a Wall Street banker, that is. Not if you’re a college student looking for a loan. Because bankers and Congress don’t intend to give you a break today.

Not if you’re one of the hundreds of thousands of workers furloughed because of the sequester. Because Congress has no intention of charging highflying banks a financial transaction tax, the revenues from which could prevent many of those cuts.

Not if you’re one of those middle class Americans who bailed out the banks and now fears renewed recklessness on Wall Street will require another rescue. Because Wall Street has persuaded Congress that it really, really should not closely regulate banks.

But, hey, they’re partying on Wall Street, right? The thing is, people are supposed to rule. Not Wall Street, not banks, not money. People rule in a democracy. This is something apparently forgotten by some in Congress. Banks are corporations, which are legal entities established under rules written by people. Their existence should advance America and Americans. Not the other way around. Many in Congress need to be reminded of that.

Start with the U.S. House of Representatives. Just last month, the House passed measures to reverse regulations in the 2010 Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Financial Protection Act and to deregulate derivatives, those high-risk financial instruments at the heart of the 2008 market collapse.

Members of the House lost sight of who they work for, who rules. Here’s a hint: It’s not banks.

Over in the Senate, by contrast, several lawmakers have made it clear they know people rule. Two groups of Senators are working to strengthen financial regulation.

A Democrat and a Republican, Sen. Sherrod Brown of Ohio and Sen. David Vitter of Louisiana, introduced legislation requiring big banks to increase the capital they must hold to cover losses. That would diminish risk of another taxpayer bailout. It would also encourage the nation’s largest banks to break into smaller financial institutions with reduced capital requirements.

Similarly, two Democrats, a Republican, and an independent in the Senate introduced legislation to update and reinstate the Glass-Steagall regulations that prevented market crashes for 70 years — from the time they were passed in 1933 in response to the Great Crash until 1999, just nine years before the 2008 crash that caused the Great Recession.

The 21st Century Glass-Steagall Act would restore the regulations that prohibited banks that use federal deposit insurance from engaging in risky Wall Street activities like swaps dealing. The key sponsor is Elizabeth Warren, the Democrat from Massachusetts who succeeded in getting the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau included in the Dodd-Frank law. She’s intent on ending too-big-to-fail banks. She says bankers are free to gamble on Wall Street, but not with the federally insured money in Main Street Americans’ checking and savings accounts.

Republican John McCain of Arizona is with her. Which is remarkable because he voted to repeal the original Glass-Steagall Act.  He says overturning Glass-Steagall was a mistake because “a culture of dangerous greed and excessive risk-taking has taken root in the banking world” imperiling everyday bank customers.

Some bankers agree with them. That includes bankers who pushed for repeal of Glass-Steagall like Sanford “Sandy” Weill. He engineered mergers of traditional and investment banks to create Citigroup. Taxpayers forked over $476 billion to rescue Citigroup, the largest of the bank bailouts.

Now, Weill says investment and insured banking should divorce. Joining him are Phil Purcell, former chairman and CEO of Morgan Stanley, and David Komansky, former CEO of Merrill Lynch.

Despite that support and despite the fact that the four biggest banks now are 30 percent larger than they were at the time of the crash and continue high-risk practices, previous attempts to revive Glass-Steagall failed. Warren and McCain aren’t backing down, though. They want bank rules that protect Americans. They don’t believe banks rule.

Warren made that clear on another matter — borrowing for tuition. She called for the interest rate on student loans to equal the rate that the Federal Reserve grants big banks.

Unfortunately, the majority in Congress failed to agree with her that the government should give students the same deal it gives banks. Instead, Congress is proposing legislation that would set the student rate at 3.85 percent for one year, but after that allow it to rise up to 8.25 percent. That rate increase would hit about 7 million students a year. But not banks.

That suggests a Congress that is ruling for banks — as does its failure to adopt a financial transaction fee. This tiny tax, about 3 cents on every $100 traded as currently proposed, would cool risky high-speed trading and raise about a third of the money needed to restore programs cut by the sequester.

Clearly, when six Wall Street banks can make $23 billion in three months, they can afford to pay this fee. Still, they’ll hand over millions to lobbyists to avoid it — just like they did to prevent reinstatement of Glass-Steagall. JPMorgan Chase spent $8 million lobbying last year; Wells Fargo, $6.8 million; Citigroup, $5.6 million.

Congress should pass the tax anyway. And Glass-Steagall. And a student loan rate matching the Federal Reserve rate for banks. Americans have the right to make the rules for corporations, particularly ones like banks that have failed spectacularly at self-governance.


Leo Gerard is the president of the United Steelworkers International union, part of the AFL-CIO. Gerard, the second Canadian to lead the union, started working at Inco’s nickel smelter in Sudbury, Ontario at age 18. For more information about Gerard, visit usw.org.
  • submit to reddit
  • Patrick S. Lovell

    What else is there? Except for JAILING the rigged con-artists that pulled the biggest heist in the history of the world. They mock the rest of us through their insidious pupateering and revolving door that is the ultimate inside game. Why wouldn’t they, everything they do is dirty pool. They’ve sold America down the river now it’s time to stop buying what they’re selling. If democracy and capitalism actually worked in our country, the informed “We the People” would have pulled our money years ago. Instead, people just continue to peter by with their heads in the sand or are of course complicit. Obama just called the system out, but again, lacks specifics. His vision was uplifting however. Now its time for details.

  • Anonymous

    The only way that Wall Street will come under control is to elect democrats. The Elizabeth Warren bill would rein in Wall Street. The republicans (a misnomer, since republicans by definition are elected by the people in a republic to represent the voter; not corporations) will vote down any bill that Wall Street does not like because if Wall Street is not happy, Wall Street will not come through with the big campaign donations. The republicans once championed business interests in the US. Now they just champion whoever pays them off. Voters, through republican efforts have been barred from the polls, unemployed, food for their children cut off, education short changed, students gouged for loans to better themselves, women are denied abortions, nevertheless, anyone can buy guns without limit.
    Democrats must not just campaign, but really educate the public.

  • scott

    We as a Nation have to pay more attention to the finance system. The Fed also makes money.The Country takes a loan and then We the People have to pay the loan back plus. We can never pay that back to a Institution that works separate of the welfare of the people.Federal Income tax started the same year as the Federal Reserve. Weird, don’t you think?

  • Anonymous

    Elect Democrats!!! What a BIG JOKE!! Both GOP & the Dems are in the Corporate pocket!!!

    power!! Look what kind of government we have in Oregon. The above the law criminal, tyrant, anarchist former A.G. Dave Frohnmayer & the rest of criminal officials of Lane County Oregon are complicit with Frohnmayer from top former A.G. Hardy Mayers who’s now working with Frohnmayer law firm Harrang..to the very small serving offices are part of Frohnmayer criminal fraudulent misconduct. Frohnmayer literally stole my fully paid Condo by forging my sister’s signature after he put a lean on it!!

    Oregon politics is as dirty as DC, NY, CA and Florida

    http://www.oregonlive.com/news/oregonian/steve_duin/index.ssf/2011/03/john_kroger_and_the_cylvia_hay.html

    Noone can sue this criminal cabal! Frohnmayer has secured both the D.A. and the City Attorney by providing Harrag Long to be in charge of these two offices

    The judiciary in Oregon is very much on his side (see Rounds v. University of Oregon, about 20 years ago.)

    http://www.wweek.com/portland/blog-30283-u_of_o_prof_files_bar_complaint_in_long_v_kroger_case.html

    http://journalism.uoregon.edu/~tgleason/j385/cases/Rounds.html

  • http://www.you-read-it-here-first.com/ John Bailo

    I really don’t think Wall Street is the crux of the problem. These banks are actually behaving rationally as financial entities by trying to control as much of the inputs and resources as affect their livelihood.

  • Enough

    I’ve lost all faith in people and government these days. It just seems that there is no right or wrong in the minds of most people including those in business and office. It may have always been this way for America but for me I didn’t believe so. It might just be the daily access to the truth through the Internet which has emptied my heart of hope and the dream of a world that believed in virtue. All I feel is empty and hopeless these days. This is the new America for many.

  • rain,adustbowlstory

    Thanks for this article, because I would suggest that the last refuge from despair now is to simply pick out a few stellar individuals who are fighting the good fight–Elizabeth Warren comes to mind–and give them all your support (and some of your money) so they can fight on, even if it’s a losing battle.

    I keep thinking of the Kennedy phrase–wasn’t it “long twilight battle”? We will never surrender.

  • lgfromillinois

    Old Testament prophets called such people “shepards who feed themselves”, who “scatter my flock” and “do not feed my sheep”. They are leaders (shepards) who with their greed destroy what they say they cherish, America.

  • Sweet Sixteen~But Wicked Smart

    My ex husb was an exec at a trading desk and paid me $40 million in the divorce. Now he is a disenfranchised male.