The Silence of Science

  • submit to reddit

This article first appeared in the January/February issue of Orion magazine.

Seneca Lake seen from Sampson State Park in Romulus, N.Y. Reverend Gary Judson was arrested for trespassing while protesting the Missouri-based Inergy Midstreams plan to store propane, butane and methane (natural gas) from the fracking fields of Pennsylvania in abandoned salt caverns on the west shore of the lake. (Wikimedia Commons/Scieri12)

The last time I thought about the possible crimes of a Methodist minister, I was a teenager. The minister in question was the one who sent shivers of Holy Spirit zinging through the pews of our church every Sunday. The accusation: adultery. More or less simultaneously, charges were leveled at my school principal over an incident involving an undercover drug agent, and the president of the United States was revealed to be surrounded by burglars and plumbers. Thus were the heads of my church, school and country laid low.

Reprinted from the Jan/Feb 2013 issue of Orion magazine. Reprinted with permission.

The lesson I took from all this was that trails of corruption invariably lead to the Justice Department and that the coverup likely involves school board members and deacons. And Jesus is no Deep Throat.

There were two places to go from here: nihilism or biology. I chose biology. With unifying principles and enduring beauty — pollination, photosynthesis — the study of life seemed a trustworthy place to plant my flag. Au revoir, Methodist Church.

I was thinking about all this as I sat, forty years later, at the trial of Methodist minister Gary Judson (age seventy-two), whose fate I had come to care deeply about. I had a front-row seat in the courtroom in the town of Reading — which is tucked among the Finger Lakes and Riesling grapes of upstate New York — when the reverend walked down the aisle. Slowly. As though to present the weekly offering.

      We give Thee but Thine own,
      Whate’er the gift may be;
      All that we have is Thine alone,
      A trust, O Lord, from Thee.

But the table before him was a judge’s bench, not an altar, and the white-haired judge who stared down from it demanded, with no benediction, a plea to the charge of trespassing at the Seneca Lake Compressor Station.

“Guilty,” said the white-haired minister who stared back up. Whereupon a substantial fine was levied. And then the clerk asked — I am not making this up — “Visa or MasterCard?” and the surrealness of the question triggered a call and response among the assembled onlookers.

“I’d like to pay his fine, your honor,” called out a man from the back.

“So would I!” called out another standing by the door.

“You cannot all pay,” groused the judge. But wallets appeared from pockets everywhere — including those belonging to congregants outside the overflowing courthouse who had been watching the proceedings through the window and who were now jimmying it open and passing twenty-dollar bills through the crack.

A minute later, a pile of cash amounting to twice the fine was being counted and stacked in the front row. No collection plate needed.

  • submit to reddit

BillMoyers.com encourages conversation and debate around issues, events and ideas related to content on Moyers & Company and the BillMoyers.com website.

  • The editorial staff reserves the right to take down comments it deems inappropriate.
  • Profanity, personal attacks, hate speech, off-topic posts, advertisements and spam will not be tolerated.
  • Do not intentionally make false or misleading statements, impersonate someone else, break the law, or condone or encourage unlawful activity.

If your comments consistently or intentionally make this community a less civil and enjoyable place to be, you and your comments will be excluded from it.

We need your help with this. If you feel a post is not in line with the comment policy, please flag it so that we can take a look. Comments and questions about our policy are welcome. Please send an email to feedback@billmoyers.com

Find out more about BillMoyers.com's privacy policy and terms of service.

  • Anonymous

    Eloquent and essential.

  • EverBlue

    There is nothing right about Inergy’s history, present actions, or future plans, period! They are among the growing number of entities that can only see far enough ahead to pave a way for their own prosperity. I liken their actions to indicate an attitude of, “damn the torpedoes”, or “take no prisoners”, and “I want what’s mine”. These people have no souls.

  • http://www.facebook.com/loretta.brockmeier Loretta Brockmeier

    Couldn’t some of those chemicals end up in Inergy’s stockholders’ living rooms?

  • Helen A. L.

    Loretta, I believe you meant to sound sinister (promoting bombing, ar you?), but the truth is that MOST of us have the various “chemicals” Sandra rants against ALREADY IN USE in our houses and patios. Butane in my lighter for candles; salt crystals in my shaker on the table; salt pellets in my water-softener; detergents and emulsifiers under my sink and in the bathroom and at the laundry. Propane at the grill on the patio. So, Loretta, have a hard dose of reality.

    Oh, you use ‘natural lye-soap’ so you don’t really use “chemicals”? Just what do you think ‘lye’ is anyway? …..sodium hydroxide, NaOH, a common and useful “industrial chemical”.

  • http://www.facebook.com/helen.rogers.526 Helen Rogers

    Please please read the article then speak out against fracking. Fracking is destroying the environment in many many ways.

  • RBredahl

    Any specific actions organized? Petitions? Responsible environmental groups applying donations?

  • FEHL

    There are chemicals & then there are CHEMICALS. They are not all insidious. You should stop using as much of them as p[ossible. Live more simply & use your time to help nature.

  • Ne SSa

    If you believe what you are saying, Helen A. L., then you are either disingenuous or completely uniformed. Work for the corporation?