‘American Winter’ Arrives at Capitol Hill

  • submit to reddit

We’re proud to collaborate with The Nation in sharing insightful journalism related to income inequality in America. The following is an excerpt from Nation contributor Greg Kaufmann’s “This Week in Poverty” column.

Diedre Melson, John Cox and Pamela Thatcher. (Credit: Don Mathis.)
Diedre Melson, John Cox and Pamela Thatcher. (Credit: Don Mathis.)

On Thursday, Senator Jeff Merkley (D-OR) got off to an auspicious start as chair of the Banking Subcommittee on Economic Policy by doing something that is all too novel — inviting people with the most at stake in economic policy decisions to testify in Congress.

Three Oregonians featured in the HBO documentary American Winter joined four public policy experts at the subcommittee’s first hearing, entitled “The State of the American Dream — Economic Policy and the Future of the Middle Class.”

Senator Merkley set the context with some powerful and totally depressing statistics, including that between 1989-2010, hourly productivity grew more than three times as fast as wages did during that time; the bottom 20 percent of wage earners saw their average hourly wages decline by 30 cents; the next lowest 20 percent saw their earnings decline by 4.3 percent. In contrast, over that same period, the top 20 percent of workers enjoyed a nearly 30 percent increase in earnings.

And while middle class earnings have declined, Senator Merkley noted that “the costs of basic features of the middle class such as public college, rent and utilities, and health expenditures have increased between 41 and 80 percent between 1970 and 2009.”

“The data seems to suggest that ordinary families have been slowly hurting for awhile, the financial crisis and recession nearly crushed them and our budget austerity policies are making it even worse,” said the senator.

Certainly the witnesses from American Winter agreed with his analysis.

Diedre Melson started working at age thirteen and, after graduating high school, enrolled in college. But after two and a half years she could no longer afford it, and so she transferred to “a career school” where she was certified as a medical assistant, cardiac technician and phlebotomist.

She obtained a good job at the Alpha Plasma Clinic but was laid off along with 1,500 other workers when it was shut down during the recession. She was unemployed for two years before finding minimum wage work, and she received SNAP (food stamps) and housing assistance. But even with this assistance, she needed to sell scrap metal — as well as her plasma once or twice a week — to support her four children, two of whom are in college. She now works full-time for the 211info social services hotline and earns $13.50 an hour, but she still must turn to SNAP assistance to feed her family.

Melson said she is frustrated with a media that “exploits” instances of abuse of the safety net rather than showing the vast majority of people who turn to it in the midst of a financial crisis.

“[We] are not the people we see in the media — people taking advantage of the system — we’re the working poor,” she said. “We’re people who get up every day, and try to pay our fair share, and try to pay our dues. But despite our efforts, we’re sinking.”

John Cox is also no stranger to hard work. He was raised on a cattle ranch and said, “From the time I could walk it seemed like I was having to get up at 4 a.m. to feed the cattle in the winter — and that wasn’t going out in the barn, that was in open pastures.” He was taught by his “parents, grandparents and church” to believe in the American Dream, and his father constantly told him, “You take care of your job and your job will take care of you.”

Cox paid his way through college — which he noted was much cheaper then — working various jobs, including commercial fishing in Alaska, and sweeping volcanic ash from parking lots after the eruption of Mount St. Helens.

“I hadn’t been without a job since I was about 12 years old — until October 2008,” he said.

That’s when he was laid off from his position as an accountant. He was confident he would be rehired quickly, but ended up exhausting $35,000 in savings and $35,000 in his 401(k) to support himself and his 12-year-old son, who has Downs Syndrome.

“After the dreaded six months of unemployment, employers won’t look at you. They’re not anxious to hire a person of my age anyway,” said Cox, who is in his 50s.

After a year and a half, Cox applied for unemployment benefits that he “had always thought of as for other people.”

“I still am putting out job applications left and right. I’ve even looked at minimum wage jobs — if it was just me, I would have no problem,” said Cox. “But when you work for minimum wage and you have to pay for day care or a baby sitter, it’s just a wash. You can’t afford to work and pay a baby sitter.”

Wells Fargo is now trying to foreclose on his home — he owes far more on his mortgage than his home is worth (as did nearly one in four homeowners in the first quarter of 2013, according to Senator Merkley). Cox had purchased the house so that his son would have a “nest egg in the future when [I’m] not around.”

Pam Thatcher and her husband saved up before having their first child so that she could stop teaching preschool and work as a stay-at-home mother. But after they had their second child, her husband was laid off.

“We cut back on every possible extra expense and carefully used our savings to pay for the basics like rent, food and diapers,” said Thatcher. “It wasn’t long before cutting corners was no longer enough and we were faced with the grim prospect of going without, or turning to social services and government assistance for help. Thank goodness there was help when we needed it.”

Thatcher said that prior to her own need for assistance, she thought “it was easy for people who depended on government programs” and that “the system bred abuse.” Now she sees that safety net programs “help keep families like [mine] just barely above water.”

“Something has gone wrong when instead of investing in programs that will help families get back on their feet, our elected officials are making cuts,” she said. “When you cut funding for SNAP, TANF or WIC you are making the decision to take away what little support people have to keep the lights on, or food on the table.”

Her husband has found a new job, but like so many other workers, he is earning a much lower salary than he was before the recession.

“Now, even with full-time work, we still struggle to make ends meet,” said Thatcher.

The panel’s public policy experts — Princeton economics professor, Dr. Atif Mian, Demos senior policy analyst Amy Traub and venture capitalist Nick Hanauer — suggested many reforms to help rebuild the middle class, including raising the minimum wage to $15 per hour; investing in public education and reducing student loan rates to make college affordable; rebuilding the right to organize and collectively bargain; and insisting that the wealthy and corporations pay a fair share of taxes as they did in the past.

Senator Merkley wondered if — absent such policy initiatives — “[we] are in danger of a national cycle of depressed aspirations replacing the motivating vision of the American Dream?”

Mian, Traub and Hanauer did an excellent job laying out the economic trends that are diminishing the middle class, and proposing ways to reverse these trends. But it was the voice of the people — represented by three Oregonians — that made this hearing so meaningful. Kudos to Senator Merkley for making that happen. I candidly think it will take 1,000 Diedres, Pams and Johns doing sit-ins in Congressional offices — along with other advocates for the poor and the middle class — to create the kind of change that is needed.

But in the meantime, Senator Merkley opened the door to authentic experience in his subcommittee, and I hope he will keep it open.

Greg Kaufmann is a freelance writer and Nation contributor covering poverty in America, primarily through his blog, This Week in Poverty. His work has also been featured on MSNBC’s Melissa Harris-Perry show, CBSNews.com, NPR.org, WashingtonPost.com, Common Dreams and Alternet. He serves as an adviser for the Economic Hardship Reporting Project.
  • submit to reddit
  • Anonymous

    This whole “hat in hand” thing is starting to really get old. Begging politicians to not give in to corruption, “We demand that you do what’s right for the American people”, really? One petition after another telling congressman so-and-so do not do such-and-such. It all reeks of freshly dumped bs. It seems, to me, that most “politicians” are fully capable of noshing a croissant at a five star restaurant while perusing the latest austerity bill.

  • http://www.judithgargyi.vpweb.com Judith

    Where is mainstream media coverage of session like this?

  • Mark Boysen

    I agree the mainstream media should cover this– my situation is similar except I am a single psychotherapist who lost his career due to side effects of bells palsy meds which ruined my mental health and made me a poor advocate for myself. I hate to say so, but the safety net is really non-existent or a monopoly of people who just want to shut you up with heavy traquilizers— bi polar kick backs still exist apparently because after being ok with antidepressants since prozac in 85, all they want to give me is anti-psychotics….etc….or kick me off. I’m about done, everyone in my life seems to think the safety net exists– and so have not helped. And they wonder why people give up? They do everything except put you in a ditch and shoot you. Sorry Bill if this is negative, you are my hero– always have been– and I just cannot believe no one is listening. And yet, they are not.

  • Chuck

    If you follow the money, you’ll notice that the banks that are foreclosing (also the biggest bailout banks) on people’s homes are the same banks that, in conjunction with the Federal Reserve, have deliberately contracted the supply of money in the same way that happened during the Great Depression. Further, that same cabal of international bankers lend every single dollar that the government uses for social programs (and all other operation expenses) at an interest rate, which is paid for by taxes. Not one congressperson, with the exceptions of Ron Paul and Dennis Kucinich (H.R. 2990), who are usually either ignored or berated by mainstream media, has insisted that we enact the only solution to all of our economic woes: Revert to a debt-free currency (because the interest is killing us), stop fractional reserve banking (the private-bank creation/counterfeiting of the money supply, which is the direct cause of rising prices), and rein the Fed in. They are the cause of every single period of inflation and deflation we’ve ever had. As long as they control the money supply, we will all continue to suffer. My heart goes out for these hardworking folks whose dreams have been shattered by the kleptocrats.

  • Anonymous

    Is Congress waiting until there are riots in the street before they do ANYTHING?

    I have to laugh when Congress decides Americans will have to work much longer, like until 70. There are no jobs! AND if you are older you are the FIRST to be laid-off usually because of your higher salary. Ask anyone in there 50s if they’ve been able to find a comparable job after being laid off. Instead of looking forward to a nice retirement, like their parents, they are scrambling just to make ends meet.

  • Anonymous

    It’s not sensational enough. They won’t cover it until there is blood involved. Then they’ll act so-o-o-o-o surprised, as if the revolution came out of nowhere.

  • Anonymous

    Senator Merkley understands that many senators can’t empathize unless they have their faces rubbed in the suffering. He’s smart to bring people to DC to speak. Too bad it’s necessary, and too bad it isn’t likely to help.

  • Walt Heinecke

    It seems like with all this ferment percolating, the anti-poverty movement, the environmental movement, education movement, that if the movements joined there could be a viable third party in this country, like the the Citizens Party.

    It could start with a simple platform of questions for any candidate:

    1. Will you vow to work with people of all perspectives and get something done in DC or the State capital? Will you put people over ideology? What’s you position on ethics?

    2. Will you close your doors to and refuse the advances of corporate lobbyists or thier PACS?

    3. Will you vow to make corporations and the wealthy pay their fair share of taxes in order to fund public programs aimed at eradicating poverty?

    4. Will you carry on the work of FDR’s second Bill of Rights nationally and at the state level?

    5. Will your educational platform start with the recognition that the acheivement gap is caused by massive income inequality and will you eradicate the student loan system that keeps middle and low income people in a state of permanent indentured slavery? Will you forgive the student loan debt of people under middle class thresholds of income?

    6.Will you put the safety of the public’s food supply above the corporate profit motive?

    7. Will you strengthen federal and state oversight and regulation of the economy, environment, transportation, communications, pharmaceuticals, etc.?

    8. Will you hold accountable those who plundered the economy in 2008?

    9. Will you stop the cycle of criminalization and the prison industry that supports it?

    10. Will you acknowledge and address in a substantive manner the problems associated with all forms of discrimination in the U.S.?


    I would work, campaign for, vote for, fund candidates who said yes to these questions. Maybe elizabeth warren will jump ship and get others to orm a new party once she gets tired of trying to work inside of this ineffective, corrupt two-party system in America.

    Different movements, unite!

  • John Snakenburg

    Give the abusers some competition they deserve … a Civilian Medical Corp. Nationalize the Health Industry, and save this nation a lot of money. I did it, and I’ve seen it work. US Army Medical Corp ’67 – 73 How about a Federal Car at an honest 75 mpg? Real online Universities with National Certification when the student is ready? A safe Federal Bank that doesn’t play games with your savings?

  • Easkey Stewart

    It would be a good idea if these Hearings were held around the country – seems to me an oxymoron to expect those most affected to travel to Washington!

  • goodjules

    So true. I couldn’t even get an interview at a large corporation. I’m in my mid-50s. I took job that paid less than I was making in the 80s with no benefits and no paid days off other than three holidays. No paid sick days or vacation. I just moved across the country to a city where housing is cheaper. Hope to find work soon.

  • James Traynor

    What a lot of nonsense. They’ll listen, they just won’t hear or they’ll dump it in the round file. It’s an old trick. Listen, commiserate and ignore. And it you take to the streets there’s always the cops just aching to use their sticks. We knew how to handle this in the ’30s and it wasn’t pretty, but it worked.

  • Sweet Sixteen~But Wicked Smart

    Look at the faces on these morons … they are smiling morons … they feel no pain because their heads and emotions are vacuous. Vacuous but still taking nourishment. They are props on the stage of life. Hey guys … Get a life! If you are really so giggly, get a room!